The importance
of the ordinary
How indeed does the script create a feeling of ordinariness, coupled
with the unexpected and the entertaining, to make a serious point about
human life and values; that we have a common need for 'true love and
companionship' and that there are 'all sorts of true love without bias
to age or gender'?
(Tanskaya, Alissa: op cit.). The opposite condition, loneliness, as Tanskaya observes in the
Cinema
Papers review, and the film touchingly points out, 'functions without
bias'.
A shot of kids playing football in a suburban backyard creates a very
ordinary opening for the script. What is perhaps unexpected is that
a grandmother is playing with them while a female friend watches from
the verandah. In the following scenes, Jeff and Harry appear to be ordinary
Australian blokes. They live in an apparently working class suburb with
its pub and greyhounds. Their jobs are ordinary: a ferry captain and
a plumber. Jeff plays football. Although they cook for each other, their
culinary efforts are unpretentious, 'bangers and mash', frozen lasagne,
and for a treat 'a nice roast'. They drink beer and argue about the
taps in the shower. Even Harry's courting of Joyce begins through a
computer dating agency, not some romantic meeting, and they go to dinner
at the local Leagues Club. All this ordinariness lulls the reader/audience
into a sense of normality, of acceptance, and allows the script to act
as instructor, promoting certain values without the reader/audience
being so acutely aware that this is being done.
It is easy to empathise with Harry as he seems so like someone we know.
This empathy is increased by the use of the direct-to-camera device.
Rather than alienating the audience by reminding them that they are
not looking at 'real life', this technique creates a conspiratorial
bond between the reader/audience and Harry. This device was also used
in
House of Cards, shown on ABC television. In this series, the
main character—who was completely amoral—obtained some audience
sympathy by his conspiratorial asides to them. It was also used to good
effect in
Alfie,
a 1960s film dealing with morals and sexuality from the point of view
of a young heterosexual male (
Alfie, film. dir.Lewis Gilbert, 1966). In
The Sum of Us, this device allows
us to look into the mind of a stroke victim, showing that the stroke
has not changed Harry's personality—and Jeff's use of direct-to-camera
device and voice-over during flashbacks very quickly has the audience's
sympathy with him.
When, after reading the script, you view the film, you will see how
the visual images in the film reinforce these ideas of ordinary life,
with its views of the suburb of Balmain, supermarket scenes and those
in the Botanic Gardens. The only time it seems to go a bit beyond the
ordinary is in the final shot included in the script of the wide sweep
of Sydney Harbour, but perhaps this too is part of the film's technique
of enticing the audience to accept the film's message.
The Role
of the Unexpected
Much has been made in reviews of
The Sum of Us of the way it
plays with the traditional Aussie male image. Reference is made to a
1975 film,
Sunday Too Far Away
, photographed by the co-director of
The Sum of Us, Geoff Burton,
and starring Jack Thompson as a shearer (
Sunday Too Far Away, film. dir. Ken Hannam, 1975). In this film, Thompson plays
the part of Foley, a gun shearer who is involved in the shearer's strike
of 1956. It deals with the camaraderie between the men and their loyalty
to the union in the tradition of Australian mateship. Thompson and the
actor John Ewart who played Ugly, stand at a communal washing tub clad
in nothing but bath towels around their waists. As they wash their underthings
their bodies wiggle to such an extent that the towels fall to the floor,
revealing bare wiggling buttocks. In
The Sum of Us, when Harry
is mashing potatoes in a pot on the stove, 'his body wiggles as he stirs
the pot' in just the same way as it did in the earlier film. This introduces
the script/film's questioning of what is really meant by the 'Aussie
male' today. Russell Crowe, as another icon of masculinity,
works with Thompson in the film to undermine our national masculine
stereotype (see his role in the film
Romper Stomper and interview in 'Metro',
Sydney Morning Herald, 24 June, 1995). Both these actors only reinforce the unexpected in the film;
the tenderness between them is already there in the script.
The Aussie male is not the only stereotype to fall to the unexpected,
as seen in the revelations about Gran's football prowess and her loving
relationship with Mary.